American Eagle to Old Navy size
The short answer
American Eagle M TALL is Old Navy M by the two brands' own charts. 6 of 10 American Eagle sizes land on a different label at Old Navy.
Both brands publish the body chest each size is cut for, so every row matches a chest, not a letter.
| American Eagle | American Eagle builds it for | Old Navy, by chart | Same label | Old Navy builds it for | Old Navy also prints |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XS | chest 35 to 36 in, neck 13.5 to 14 in, sleeve 31.5 in | XS | XS | chest 36 to 37 in, neck 13 to 13.5 in, sleeve 31.5 to 32 in | not published |
| S | chest 37 to 39 in, neck 14.5 to 15 in, sleeve 32.5 in | S | S | chest 38 to 39 in, neck 14 to 14.5 in, sleeve 32.5 to 33 in | not published |
| M | chest 40 to 42 in, neck 15 to 15.5 in, sleeve 33.5 in | M | M | chest 40 to 42 in, neck 15 to 15.5 in, sleeve 33.5 to 34 in | not published |
| M TALL | chest 40 to 42 in, neck 15 to 15.5 in, sleeve 34.5 in | M | not published | chest 40 to 42 in, neck 15 to 15.5 in, sleeve 33.5 to 34 in | not published |
| L | chest 43 to 45 in, neck 15.5 to 16 in, sleeve 34.5 in | L | L | chest 44 to 46 in, neck 16 to 16.5 in, sleeve 34.5 to 35 in | not published |
| L TALL | chest 43 to 45 in, neck 15.5 to 16 in, sleeve 35.5 in | L | not published | chest 44 to 46 in, neck 16 to 16.5 in, sleeve 34.5 to 35 in | not published |
| XL | chest 46 to 48 in, neck 16.5 to 17 in, sleeve 35.5 in | L or XL | XL | chest 44 to 46 in, neck 16 to 16.5 in, sleeve 34.5 to 35 in | not published |
| XL TALL | chest 46 to 48 in, neck 16.5 to 17 in, sleeve 36.5 in | L or XL | not published | chest 44 to 46 in, neck 16 to 16.5 in, sleeve 34.5 to 35 in | not published |
| XXL | chest 49 to 51 in, neck 17 to 18 in, sleeve 36.5 in | XL | XXL | chest 48 to 50 in, neck 17 to 17.5 in, sleeve 35.5 to 36 in | not published |
| XXXL | chest 52 to 54 in, neck 18 to 19 in, sleeve 37 in | XXL | XXXL | chest 51 to 53 in, neck 18 to 18.5 in, sleeve 36.5 to 37 in | not published |
What wearers say
Charts describe a garment, not a fit. We do not collect fit reports for this category yet, so this table is the two brands' own claims and nothing more.
Sources
- American Eagle size guide, read on 2026-09-18. American Eagle on TrueToSize
- Old Navy size guide, read on 2026-09-18. Old Navy on TrueToSize